Three MRR Attorneys Named to 2016 “Best Lawyers in America” List

2016 Best Lawyers firm logoMRR is pleased to announce that three attorneys have been named to the 2016 Edition of Best Lawyers, the oldest and most respected peer-review publication in the legal profession. Lawyers on the Best Lawyers in America list are divided by geographic region and practice areas. They are reviewed by their peers on the basis of professional expertise, and undergo an authentication process to make sure they are in current practice and in good standing.

MRR would like to congratulate Todd M. Raskin (Civil Rights law), John T. McLandrich (Civil Rights law) and Stacy V. Pollock (Education law) for being named among the Best Lawyers in America for 2016.

Todd Raskin is a founding partner of MRR and has tried more than 100 cases to conclusion in 35 years of private practice. His diverse practice focuses on civil rights and government liability defense, as well as the defense of both public and private employers. He has defended clients in state and federal courts throughout Ohio and surrounding states, including in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit and the Ohio Supreme Court.

John McLandrich, MRR’s Chairman of the Board, has defended civil claims in federal and state courts throughout Ohio for more than 25 years. He has also served as lead counsel on over 100 public entity appeals before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit.

Both Todd and John have consistently been selected Best Lawyers for Civil Rights law, in addition to each being selected as “Lawyer of The Year” by Best Lawyers in America for Civil Rights law in Cleveland, Ohio, respectively, in 2013 and 2014.

Stacy Pollock, a first-time recipient, is an associate in MRR’s Columbus office selected for her work in Education law. She is a certified Professional in Human Resources who represents and advises public and private employers in labor and workers’ compensation matters, including schools and school administrators.

About Best Lawyers®
Since it was first published in 1983, Best Lawyers® has become universally regarded as the definitive guide to legal excellence. Because Best Lawyers is based on an exhaustive peer-review survey in which almost 50,000 leading attorneys cast nearly five million votes on the legal abilities of other lawyers in their practice areas, and because lawyers are not required or allowed to pay a fee to be listed, inclusion in Best Lawyers is considered a singular honor. The Best Lawyers in America© 2015 (Copyright 2013 by Woodward/White, Inc., of Aiken, SC). For more information, visit

MRR Article: The State of Transgender Employment Discrimination

By: Neil S. Sarkar, Esq.
Mazanec, Raskin & Ryder Co., LPA

Virtually everyone has been talking over the last few months about Caitlyn Jenner, the transwoman (formerly) known as Bruce Jenner, perhaps due to the potentially polarizing nature of the subject involving how to interact with transgender persons in our society.

At the same time, many still remain unfamiliar with the laws addressing the issue of transgender discrimination, including in the workplace. Regardless of how business owners or other employers might feel personally about this subject, suffice it to say that it is here to stay as are accompanying legal obligations to ensure transgender civil rights in the workplace. With this in mind, now appears to be an opportune time to review some of the new rules in place and recent cases that may apply to employers.

In early June, 2015, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (“OSHA”) issued a guidance on transgender bathroom access. OSHA promulgated this guidance based on its pronouncement that transgender employees should have the right of restroom access that corresponds to their gender identity. This guidance has been instituted with an eye towards ensuring that transgender employees are given the right to work in a way that is consistent with how they live the rest of their daily lives—regardless of their actual birth gender.

In its guidance, OSHA cites laws that call for the idea of affording employees access to restroom facilities based on gender identity. In describing best practices, OSHA indicates that many employers have adopted written policies of their own to ensure that all employees – including transgender employees – have prompt access to appropriate facilities. Workplace safety is implicated because OSHA states that restricting employees to using only restrooms that are inconsistent with their gender identity, for example, “singles out” transgender persons and may otherwise make them avoid using bathrooms altogether while at work, potentially causing them physical injury or illness as a result. OSHA’s guidance calls for employers to find solutions that are safe and convenient and respect transgender employees.

At the same time, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (“EEOC”) recently filed an employment transgender discrimination lawsuit against a Michigan employer in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan. This region is part of the Sixth Circuit, which means that if the case is appealed, this decision could apply to employers in Ohio. In this case, the plaintiff, Aimee Stephens, formerly worked as an employee at Michigan-based funeral home, where Stephens was its funeral director. By all indications, Stephens worked there for years until one day, July 31, 2013, she sent her employer a letter that she would be undergoing a gender transition from male to female and thereafter would be wearing appropriate female business attire while on the job. In the EEOC’s complaint, it is alleged that the employer fired Stephens about two weeks later, telling Stephens that what she was “proposing to do” was unacceptable.

Filing suit, the EEOC asserted that this employer violated Stephens’ rights based on gender-based considerations, thereby violating Title VII which prohibits sex discrimination in employment. More precisely, the EEOC alleged that Stephens was fired because she failed to conform to sex or gender-based preferences, expectations or stereotypes in the workplace.

In response, the employer moved to dismiss the EEOC’s lawsuit on the grounds that transgender employees are not in a legally protected class under Title VII as other individuals are in the legally protected class based, for example, on race, color, religion, gender or national origin. Denying the employer’s motion, the Court noted that the lawsuit should proceed based on the EEOC’s legal argument that the employer in this case fired Stephens for failing to conform to its own gender-based preferences, expectations or stereotypes.

This analysis is important, and employers should take heed: had the EEOC simply argued that Stephens, as a trans-sexual, should have legally protected class status, the Court would have granted the employer’s motion to dismiss the lawsuit. Instead, the Court focused on the point that the EEOC asserted that Stephens was being discriminated against in violation of Title VII because she failed to conform to her employer’s own gender-based preferences, expectations or stereotypes. That is, Stephens was being discriminated against based on unlawful sex-stereotyping gender discrimination. As such, this lawsuit will be allowed to proceed to adjudication. Further, it is precisely the legal issue of improper gender-based stereotyping against trans-gender individuals or, in some instances, individuals with a specific sexual orientation that many employers do not understand. As such, many of these same employers, just like the funeral home in the above case, not only may not understand what they should be considering to do so as to comply with Title VII and other applicable state or local laws; they also may be subject to legal liability for failing to take proactive steps to address these issues.

Based on OSHA’s recent guidance, heightened attention to the issues of transgender discrimination, and cases such as these, it behooves employers – regardless of how they may personally feel on this topic–to do the following in order to prevent, position, and protect their business and comply with applicable laws:

  • Adopt a well drafted policy prohibiting against gender and trans-gender discrimination and harassment;
  • Provide appropriate training (including anti-harassment training) for all personnel, including both managers and employees, to identify and prevent and/or remedy gender and trans-gender discrimination and harassment;
  • Ensure that these policies also are consistent with any other personnel policies, including those concerning workplace harassment, equal employment opportunity, and social media use;
  • Consider adopting similar policies pertaining to preventing and correcting sexual orientation discrimination; and
  • Make sure your policies confirm to all applicable federal, state and local laws that apply to your workplace

For more information or if you have any questions, contact Neil at 440.287.8292 or via email at

Neil SarkarAbout the Author: Neil S. Sarkar is a Partner with Mazanec, Raskin & Ryder. He focuses his practice on employment and labor law, civil rights and government liability, in addition to counseling and litigation, business law and insurance defense. He devotes much of his practice to defending employers before the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, National Labor Relations Board and state government agencies including the Ohio Civil Rights Commission and the State Employment Relations Board.


Event: MRR to sponsor 3Chamber Luncheon featuring Congressman David Joyce

Solon Chamber of CommerceSpeaker:  Congressman David Joyce
“Washington Update”

Date: Wednesday, August 19, 2015
Where: Signature of Solon, Solon, OH 44139
Time: 11:30 am

Register: Click here for more details and to register

Program Overview

Congressman David Joyce will give his address to the Solon, Aurora and Twinsburg chambers of commerce. Find out what is going on in Washington and how it has and will affect your business.

Joyce represents Northeast Ohio’s 14th Congressional District which includes all of Lake, Geauga and Ashtabula counties and part of Cuyahoga, Summit, Trumbull and Portage counties.

Founding Partner Todd M. Raskin Admitted as Member of American Board of Trial Advocates

Todd M. RaskinMRR is pleased to announce that Todd M. Raskin has been admitted as a member of the invitation-only American Board of Trial Advocates (ABOTA).

ABOTA’s primary mission is the preservation and promotion of the civil jury trial by educating the American public about the history and value of the right to trial by jury. Admission to the national association is limited to experienced trial lawyers and judges who have demonstrated high personal character and an honorable reputation. Membership selection criteria includes a minimum number of jury trials to verdict as lead counsel.

“Membership in the American Board of Trial Advocates is a prestigious honor and we congratulate Todd on this recognition,” said firm President and Managing Partner Joseph F. Nicholas, Jr. “This speaks to Todd’s significant trial experience and dedication as a trusted advocate for his clients.”

Mr. Raskin is a founding partner of MRR, which has offices in Cleveland and Columbus, Ohio. He has tried more than 100 cases to conclusion in 35 years of private practice. Todd has a diverse practice with an emphasis on civil rights and government liability defense, as well as the defense of employers, both public and private. He also has considerable experience in the defense of professionals, including doctors, lawyers, architects, engineers, and behavioral health professionals. He has successfully represented his clients in state and federal courts throughout Ohio and surrounding states, including in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit and the Ohio Supreme Court.

Todd has been selected as an Ohio Super Lawyer during each of the past four years in the primary practice area of state, local, and municipal government liability and also during the past five years for inclusion in Best Lawyers in America in the practice area of civil rights law. Additionally, he was named “Lawyer of the Year” in Civil Rights for Cleveland, Ohio in 2013 by Best Lawyers in America. He is a Fellow of the Litigation Counsel of America and a member of the Federation of Defense and Corporate Counsel, Association of Defense Trial Attorneys, Ohio Association of Civil Trial Attorneys, Professional Liability Defense Association, and the Defense Research Institute.

Mazanec, Raskin & Ryder Joins Insuralex as Ohio Member

logo-insuralexInsuralex has announced that Mazanec, Raskin & Ryder (MRR) has been elected as the Ohio Member of the expanding Insuralex group of firms dedicated to insurance and reinsurance coverage, defense and litigation. MRR is one of 40 firms to be selected internationally.

Insuralex is a world-wide network of independent insurance and reinsurance lawyers who provide legal services to the insurance and risk management communities in the areas of coverage, defense, litigation and other related legal services. Insuralex member firms are located in Europe, North America and the Middle East.

Founding Partner of MRR, Todd M. Raskin, said, “For over 35 years we have provided services to clients in the global insurance and reinsurance market. We are delighted for the firm to be elected to membership. Working with Insuralex will be a great opportunity to offer the full range of our services in our own region, as well as contributing to the international standing and reputation of this exceptional group of lawyers.”

Insuralex’s selection process evaluates objective achievements such as clear expertise in the risk management field, as well as proven responsiveness, demonstrable client care, and peer recognition.


Pilat & Williams: 9 Ways to Handle P&C Claims Fairly ~ Featured on magazine

The balance9 Ways to Handle Property & Casualty Claims Fairly

By George V. Pilat & Terry L. Williams

Every claims representative likely considers the insurer’s general duty of good faith and fair dealing when they receive notice of a new claim, or at least they should. But what is “fair” when it comes to handling property and casualty claims? Unfortunately, the answer could be different in each of the 50 states…

Click here to view the full article on magazine OR click here to download the PDF.

MRR Defeats Product Liability, Property Damage and Environmental Claims on Behalf of an Oil Rig Gasket Manufacturer

Tom MazanecOn May 4, 2014 there was a blow-out on an oil well in Morgan County, Ohio.  The owner of the oil well brought product liability, property damage and environmental claims against the manufacturers of various component parts of the drilling rig, including Lone Star Fasteners. MRR’s Thomas S. Mazanec was retained to represent Lone Star Fasteners, the company that makes a gasket which is a critical component of the oil rig and, in fact, was damaged in the blow-out.

The total value of Plaintiff’s claims was in the area of $16 to $20 million. Mazanec put together a team of metallurgists and oil field experts who spent a great deal of time not only in Ohio but also traveling to Houston, Texas to participate in testing of the various component parts.

As a result of Mazanec’s efforts, his team of experts and Lone Star Fasteners’ collaborative staff, MRR was able to defeat the claims of the Plaintiff, convincing the oil well owner to abandon his claim against Lone Star Fasteners.

Mazanec, Raskin & Ryder is #ALLinCLE

MRR is #Allin


MRR’s Controller Named National Association of Professional Women’s “VIP Woman of the Year”

Christina BidwellMRR is proud to announce that Christina M. Bidwell, CCM & Controller, has been named “VIP Woman of the Year” by the National Association of Professional Women (NAPW). Each year a handful of professional women across the nation are honored by NAPW with this distinguished award. With over 600,000 members and nearly 300 local chapters, the NAPW is one of the largest and most-recognized networking organizations of professional women in the United States.

We couldn’t be more thrilled for Chris on this much-deserved achievement,” said Joseph F. Nicholas, Jr., MRR’s President and Managing Partner. “She is a critical member of our team and is one of the most professional and committed individuals I’ve had the pleasure of working with during my career.”

Ms. Bidwell is responsible for the overall strategic financial planning and management of both administrative and financial operations for MRR. She is a financial and operational leader with experience in both privately held and publicly traded organizations, specializing in professional service based and private-equity industries.

Chris began her career as a finance/treasury manager and analyst for a multinational manufacturing company and has spent a considerable amount of time since performing strategic development and general accounting functions for both public and privately held companies.

About National Association of Professional Women®  NAPW defines success as “owning your own power.” As the largest, most-recognized networking organization of professional women in the country, spanning virtually every industry and profession, the National Association of Professional Women (NAPW) is a powerfully vibrant networking community with over 600,000 members and nearly 300 Local Chapters. NAPW members have diverse backgrounds, beliefs, perspectives and lifestyles with one common bond – their ability to succeed.

Solon Chamber of Commerce features MRR in April 2015 – Member Spotlight


The Solon Chamber of Commerce features Mazanec, Raskin & Ryder in its April 2015 Member Spotlight.

Joe Nicholas, President and Managing Partner, says, “The thing we like best about being in Solon is that it lends itself to all areas of Northeast Ohio. We are situated at a great mid-point for most of our firm’s local and regional business activity. Solon, in particular, and Northeast Ohio in general, is also home to so many diverse businesses, innovators, and leaders in their respective fields and industries. The greatest value we have found from being a Chamber member is networking and connecting with our area’s talented and innovative business leaders….”

Check out the full article and e-newsletter here.